There's a good article written in 2007 about hydraulically operated Brake Light Switches, specifically those fitted to classic Volvo models.
Being an American article it does have some amusing DIY solutions to installing alternative switches, something they could/can get away with since few US States have any form of vehicle inspection regime.
Good Minor Matters article but what it doesn't show or illustrate is that the original Lucas switches had a very different internal design and they lasted for decades without issue. These old switches did "snap" shut thus minimising any potential for internal arcing. So the Minor Matters article slightly misses the point. The issue is with the modern switches not the whole idea of a hydraulic pressure operated switch.
So just to clarify, my switch is at fault and the wiring it probably okay? Or is it possible there is issue with the wiring hence why the switch has failed?
I really appreciate everyone’s advice on this, and I shall take a look at those articles attached
mrs.smith2012 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 6:40 pm
So just to clarify, my switch is at fault and the wiring it probably okay? Or is it possible there is issue with the wiring hence why the switch has failed?
I really appreciate everyone’s advice on this, and I shall take a look at those articles attached
mrs.smith2012 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 6:40 pm
So just to clarify, my switch is at fault and the wiring it probably okay? Or is it possible there is issue with the wiring hence why the switch has failed?
I really appreciate everyone’s advice on this, and I shall take a look at those articles attached
Yes your switch is at fault. The buzzer in the boot area is unlikely to have had anything to do with the failure as such buzzers draw a tiny current in comparison to the current drawn by the brake light bulbs. Without actually being able to see and test the wiring in the boot nobody can guarantee that there is no fault there which is why I suggested that the ridiculous and unnecessary wiring is removed.
As Berni says, some strange things have been done to your car by the previous owner and in due course it may be a good idea to address these issues. I would definitely have a look at the amp ratings of the fuses in the additional fuse box. If the amp rating is too high, the wiring can melt and catch fire in the event of a short rather than the fuse blowing as it should.
Stephen
1969 1098cc Convertible “Xavier” which I have owned since 1989.
mrs.smith2012 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 6:40 pm
So just to clarify, my switch is at fault and the wiring it probably okay? Or is it possible there is issue with the wiring hence why the switch has failed?
I really appreciate everyone’s advice on this, and I shall take a look at those articles attached
Yes your switch is at fault. The buzzer in the boot area is unlikely to have had anything to do with the failure as such buzzers draw a tiny current in comparison to the current drawn by the brake light bulbs. Without actually being able to see and test the wiring in the boot nobody can guarantee that there is no fault there which is why I suggested that the ridiculous and unnecessary wiring is removed.
As Berni says, some strange things have been done to your car by the previous owner and in due course it may be a good idea to address these issues. I would definitely have a look at the amp ratings of the fuses in the additional fuse box. If the amp rating is too high, the wiring can melt and catch fire in the event of a short rather than the fuse blowing as it should.
Stephen
I really do appreciate the feedback, thank you, and yes even if changing the switch fixes the issue it has brought my attention to Nellie’s odd wiring arrangement so I’ll be addressing that
With the ignition OFF, take both wires off the switch and join them together, wrapping the joint with insulating tape so it doesn't touch any metalwork or the switch itself.
Turn the ignition ON. If the brake lights come on, and the fuse doesn't blow, this suggests there is no fault with the wiring or light fittings.
If the fuse blows, then you have a wring problem as well as a broken switch; which - as Berni says - is an unlikely scenario.
I have known bulbs to look OK but still either short to earth or go incredibly high resistance which causes too great a load for the fuse. With all wiring in normal position, remove both tail/brake light bulbs and then insert new fuse, switch on ign and press brake pedal. Fuse blows = wiring problem, fuse OK = faulty bulb.
If a bulb issue then fit one bulb at a time to prove the faulty one, or just replace both.
If wiring, then leave the bulbs out and then you can use the resistance (ohms) setting on your meter to check for the wiring short to earth. Likely places are in the boot and the lamp unit wiring, either where it goes through the wing or in the bulb holder.
simmitc wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 11:04 am
I have known bulbs to look OK but still either short to earth or go incredibly high resistance which causes too great a load for the fuse. With all wiring in normal position, remove both tail/brake light bulbs and then insert new fuse, switch on ign and press brake pedal. Fuse blows = wiring problem, fuse OK = faulty bulb.
If a bulb issue then fit one bulb at a time to prove the faulty one, or just replace both.
If wiring, then leave the bulbs out and then you can use the resistance (ohms) setting on your meter to check for the wiring short to earth. Likely places are in the boot and the lamp unit wiring, either where it goes through the wing or in the bulb holder.
I think Simon's plan crossed in the post with mine.
Implement his plan only if my plan blows the fuse But do it with the switch bypassed, as the existing switch will blow the fuse anyway.
Incidentally the ghost of Mr Ohm tells me that a bulb going high resistance won't overload a fuse . I'm sure Simon meant low resistance.
Thank you both… I had actually tried Mike’s method today… used a spare piece of wire to bridge the gap between the connectors, essentially removing the switch from the equation… and what do you know! No fuse blow outs and I have working brake lights!
So it’s most definitely the switch. I’m about to order a new one and I’ll be educating myself over the weekend ready to fit that next week.
I will still have the wiring looked at in due course because yeah… it’s a mess
Really really appreciate the help and feedback with this all!
Great stuff. Definitely the switch. You may need to buy or borrow some tools to do the switch. It’s not something you can do properly with improvised tools. ESM sell the switch.
Stephen
1969 1098cc Convertible “Xavier” which I have owned since 1989.
Glad you've got to the bottom of it. When working on the switch, first clean the area thoroughly. Next grip the union into which the switch screws - mole grips with some cloth on the jaws will work well. If you do not grip the union, then it will often twist and damage the pipes. A deep socket or box spanner is the best tool to hold the switch itself. If you have a clean dropper or syringe, then it is a good idea to fill the switch with brake fluid prior to fitting - this avoids an air bubble. Surface tension and atmospheric pressure will keep most of the fluid in the switch when it is turned the right way up; but use a cloth to protect surrounding paintwork from drips.
Thank you,
I have a friend coming over to assist and he owns every tool under the sun…and worst case…I know an excellent mechanic who can help me out in a pinch… but I’ll have to pay him so I’d like to change the switch myself!
I shall be watching videos and making note of all these tips. Switch is ordered off ESM so I imagine I’ll have that by Monday at the latest
mrs.smith2012 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 4:04 pm
Thank you,
I have a friend coming over to assist and he owns every tool under the sun…and worst case…I know an excellent mechanic who can help me out in a pinch… but I’ll have to pay him so I’d like to change the switch myself!
I shall be watching videos and making note of all these tips. Switch is ordered off ESM so I imagine I’ll have that by Monday at the latest
Perfect. The switch can be very tight and reluctant to move. Good luck!
Stephen
1969 1098cc Convertible “Xavier” which I have owned since 1989.
geoberni wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 5:02 pm
I found a 22mm Flare nut Crowfoot fits nicely, used on the end of an extension bar.
For those who don't know what a flare nut crowfoot is, it's when it has the extra flats rather than being like an open end spanner.
Crowfoot.JPG
It depends whether it is an original or a modern switch. The originals are significantly larger in diameter and naturally enough, Imperial. A deep socket, very long extension bar that extends above the top of the radiator and a breaker bar makes it very easy but you do have to jam or hold the union from turning.
Stephen
Stephen
1969 1098cc Convertible “Xavier” which I have owned since 1989.
Not a question for the OP, but to the forum...
If some of the latest switches are unreliable (due to their low tolerance to 3.5A arcing with incandescent bulbs), is it worth fitting suppression across the switch? eg a condensor designed for the distributor points (switching a similar current), or the diode (?) used in the SU pump.
mike1864 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 5:22 pm
Not a question for the OP, but to the forum...
If some of the latest switches are unreliable (due to their low tolerance to 3.5A arcing with incandescent bulbs), is it worth fitting suppression across the switch? eg a condensor designed for the distributor points (switching a similar current), or the diode (?) used in the SU pump.
You can fit a relay with a built in fly-back diode. This reduces the current going through the switch enormously. Alternatively you can fit LED brake light bulbs or both LED bulbs and relay with diode. I suppose you could use a TVS diode as used in the SU fuel pump. Fitting such a diode would be rather easy. 2x female Lucar piggy back connectors one on either diode lead, connect across the switch and then connect the usual leads as normal. Would this actually work in that application though? In the fuel pump the TVS diode prevents the high voltage spikes from the field collapsing in the coil but in the brake switch there is no coil making high voltage spikes, it the current.
Stephen
ade1f44f-afac-46ce-9b51-959a8b2c2c74.jpg (667.07 KiB) Viewed 97 times
1969 1098cc Convertible “Xavier” which I have owned since 1989.
I have to admit I’m a little concerned about the reliability of the later switches but don’t have much choice right now. I do plan to convert her to LEDs for a start in the hope that it helps
geoberni wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 5:02 pm
I found a 22mm Flare nut Crowfoot fits nicely, used on the end of an extension bar.
For those who don't know what a flare nut crowfoot is, it's when it has the extra flats rather than being like an open end spanner.
Crowfoot.JPG
It depends whether it is an original or a modern switch. The originals are significantly larger in diameter and naturally enough, Imperial. A deep socket, very long extension bar that extends above the top of the radiator and a breaker bar makes it very easy but you do have to jam or hold the union from turning.
Stephen
Stephen
I’m not actually sure if it’s original or modern? I suppose I’ll find out next week