Page 1 of 3

Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 7:31 am
by Wes
I've had my engine given the once over by my local classic car garage and my fears have been realised. The engine is tired/worn and on its way out. But the mechanic said the engine still pulls OK and everything else about the car & drive train was excellent. So for the miles, I do, and until funds allow, I'm looking at palliative care. The only real pressing issue is the smoke coming out of the breather and the fact that at a stop in traffic it come out from the engine bay and looks like theres a small fire under the bonnet. So how can i mediate (bodge) this smoke issue?

1. Would a Ø17mm breather filter work?
2. A pipe existing somewhere else?
3. A pipe that comes up and joins the rocker breather into the air filter?
4. Guessing a bung in the pipe end is a complete no-no?
5. Any other ideas?

Thanks

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 9:03 am
by mobylette
I used to drive the works Vauxhall Viva van with a badly worn engine. The mechanics had drilled a hole in the bonnet and put the breather through. It was like driving a small train! Perhaps this is not a solution for you though.

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 9:10 am
by Wes
mobylette wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 9:03 am I used to drive the works Vauxhall Viva van with a badly worn engine. The mechanics had drilled a hole in the bonnet and put the breather through. It was like driving a small train! Perhaps this is not a solution for you though.
hmmm maybe not :-)

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 11:09 am
by oliver90owner
It would seem the only means of removing the smoke from the atmosphere is to direct it into the induction manifold. Putting it to a position outside the air filter will very quickly block the filter with oily deposits, if it is a paper filter medium.

If the reason for the excessive crankcase compression is worn bores or rings, nothing else will happen - apart from just getting worse.

If the cause is broken rings/piston lands, the engine may soon require extra repairs or fail completely.

One slight improvement may be to retard the timing slightly if it is presently too far advanced.

Blocking the crankcase will only cause increased pressure and likely drive oil through the rear crankcase scroll , perhaps causing clutch failure due to oil contamination.

As I see it, the only likely approach would be to direct the excess crankcase pressure away from the area, to where it is not a nuisance to you - but would adversely affect other road users - in particular any pedestrians who may be breathing in the toxic pollution from your engine. Not a good solution.

One of the reasons why I now drive an electric car is to reduce pollution - particularly for other road users and pedestrians. Fossil-burning engines are bad enough emitting tail-pipe toxins, without extra pollution from engines in poor conditions. Get my point?

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 11:31 am
by Wes
oliver90owner wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 11:09 am As I see it, the only likely approach would be to direct the excess crankcase pressure away from the area, to where it is not a nuisance to you - but would adversely affect other road users - in particular any pedestrians who may be breathing in the toxic pollution from your engine. Not a good solution.

One of the reasons why I now drive an electric car is to reduce pollution - particularly for other road users and pedestrians. Fossil-burning engines are bad enough emitting tail-pipe toxins, without extra pollution from engines in poor conditions. Get my point?
Wholeheartedly agree. Just buying myself some time.

As an engineer working in the field of renewable power/fuels, yes you've reduced the pollution at the exhaust pipe for UK road users but not from the life cycle. EVs are more polluting in the early phases due to energy-intensive mining and battery cell production, not to mention the plethora of forever chemicals/plastics involved. But you could argue you'd have those in a new ICE car too. The whole renewable space is a mine field when it comes to "green" claims! My fav was a proposal I worked on to manufacture Solar panels in Saudi Arabia. Trouble was Middle Eastern sand wasnt good enough quality for the glass so sand had to be shipped to the desert from China!

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 12:08 pm
by Bill_qaz
A breather catch can would be a good temp solution, removing t oil from the fumes and lessening the smoke.
Screenshot_20261005-120422_Samsung Browser.jpg
Screenshot_20261005-120422_Samsung Browser.jpg (18.05 KiB) Viewed 4550 times

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 1:06 pm
by Wes
Bill_qaz wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 12:08 pm A breather catch can would be a good temp solution, removing t oil from the fumes and lessening the smoke.Screenshot_20261005-120422_Samsung Browser.jpg
Ive just been looking at theses. seems a good solution.

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 1:34 pm
by 59Elva
Wes,
So have you tried the Rislone High Mileage Ring Seal Smoke Repair that you posted about earlier? My experience is the oil additive approach is generally disappointing. STP seems to be a viscosity booster that has quieted minor ticking and maybe slightly improved oil consumption but certainly not at the level that the advertising claims. I used a Lucas fuel treatment in my old Kia that appeared to clean the injectors. It did nothing in my Weber equipped MGB.

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 1:37 pm
by Wes
59Elva wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 1:34 pm Wes,
So have you tried the Rislone High Mileage Ring Seal Smoke Repair that you posted about earlier? My experience is the oil additive approach is generally disappointing. STP seems to be a viscosity booster that has quieted minor ticking and maybe slightly improved oil consumption but certainly not at the level that the advertising claims. I used a Lucas fuel treatment in my old Kia that appeared to clean the injectors. It did nothing in my Weber equipped MGB.
No i just saw this as i'm looking for ideas to keep my car going a bit longer so wondered if anyone had tried

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 3:39 pm
by Sleeper
Wes

No 3 , just burn it off ( for now.... ) .

John

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 3:57 pm
by Wes
Sleeper wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 3:39 pm Wes

No 3 , just burn it off ( for now.... ) .

John
Thanks John. Ive bought a cheap catch can and some piping to the air cleaner so let see if this works

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 6:51 pm
by les
Wes wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 11:31 am
oliver90owner wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 11:09 am As I see it, the only likely approach would be to direct the excess crankcase pressure away from the area, to where it is not a nuisance to you - but would adversely affect other road users - in particular any pedestrians who may be breathing in the toxic pollution from your engine. Not a good solution.

One of the reasons why I now drive an electric car is to reduce pollution - particularly for other road users and pedestrians. Fossil-burning engines are bad enough emitting tail-pipe toxins, without extra pollution from engines in poor conditions. Get my point?
EVs are more polluting in the early phases due to energy-intensive mining and battery cell production, not to mention the plethora of forever chemicals/plastics involved.
Imagine the battery production needed when/if everyone buys electric. That’s another point to get !

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 7:41 pm
by 59Elva
I don’t see a downside to trying the oil additive. Its a cheap bet that might payoff.
I read a story about traffic camera sabotage over there:

“Rees denied all charges, but the court heard that he had run Facebook groups that agitated against the rollout of the network of smart surveillance cameras enabling the Ultra-Low Emission Zone initiative of London Mayor Sadiq Khan. Under the now well established system, owners of cars with older engines — which the Mayor decries as being more polluting — have to pay a steep daily fee to drive in and around London.”

Are Minors being taxed out of London or elsewhere? It would be ironic as they are featured in so many of the British tv shows that we see over here. Probably more than any other make or model with the possible exception of the black London taxis. Weren’t the taxis diesel?
Does the MMOC have a publicity agent that promotes Minors in film and tv?

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 8:43 pm
by Bill_qaz
[/quote]
Imagine the battery production needed when/if everyone buys electric. That’s another point to get !
[/quote]

We don't have a national grid to support if we all went EV
Nor the real estate on forecourts for enough charging points, we can't all have home charging.
Not to mention pollution from increased tyre wear due to the extra weight of EV.

LONG LIVE ICE :tu1:

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 8:51 pm
by svenedin
I think this engine could be palliated by having an oil separator chimney type tappet chest breather fitted in place of the swan-neck type and plumbed in to a PCV valve on the correct manifold. This does require sourcing the parts needed which would not be quick. The right manifold is quite rare now. The oil separator would almost certainly need cleaning out and re-stuffing with stainless steel pot scourer. This is the system that my 1969 10ME engine Minor runs.

Stephen

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 9:24 pm
by les
Just watching a programme that mentions mining for ingredients to make batteries, the nickel has polluted the once pristine rivers and is interfering with the populations access to water. Perhaps not as clever as may first appear to praise electric so much.

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 11:09 pm
by Bill_qaz
les wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 9:24 pm Just watching a programme that mentions mining for ingredients to make batteries, the nickel has polluted the once pristine rivers and is interfering with the populations access to water. Perhaps not as clever as may first appear to praise electric so much.
:tu1: yes just watched and thats just one of many.

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Tue Oct 06, 2026 7:14 am
by Wes
Bill_qaz wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 11:09 pm
les wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 9:24 pm Just watching a programme that mentions mining for ingredients to make batteries, the nickel has polluted the once pristine rivers and is interfering with the populations access to water. Perhaps not as clever as may first appear to praise electric so much.
:tu1: yes just watched and thats just one of many.
Me too and thought of this conversation. And lets not get into Cobalt mining.

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Tue Oct 06, 2026 2:19 pm
by Wes
les wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 9:24 pm Just watching a programme that mentions mining for ingredients to make batteries, the nickel has polluted the once pristine rivers and is interfering with the populations access to water. Perhaps not as clever as may first appear to praise electric so much.
Lets no forget the 150kg of ore that must be mined to get 1kg or pure nickel. So if each car has 30kg, that's 4.5Te of ore mined per car.

Then there's the acres of tropical rainforest felled to make way for mines and plastic producing plants. Mind you that doesn't begin to compare to the millions of acres of rainforest felled for tea plantations!

Like i said, a mine-field!

Re: Crankcase Breather Smoke

Posted: Tue Oct 06, 2026 2:52 pm
by oliver90owner
Bill_qaz wrote: ↑Mon Oct 05, 2026 8:43 pm
Imagine the battery production needed when/if everyone buys electric. That’s another point to get !
[/quote]

We don't have a national grid to support if we all went EV
Nor the real estate on forecourts for enough charging points, we can't all have home charging.
Not to mention pollution from increased tyre wear due to the extra weight of EV.

LONG LIVE ICE :tu1:
[/quote]

All a load of codswallop, IMO.

The change-over tomelectric will not be instant, so only those cars scrapped each year will likely need to be replaced. Very few buy a new car every year, so that argument immediately gets trashed. Batteries, if/when scrapped, are better than 95% recyclable. The cars are already highly recyclable, so no real change there.

It will take several years for all cars to be electric, won’t it? Night-time use of electric for home charging would not overload the grid in the foreseeable future. There are load-spreading opportunities for CPOs (batteries or more renewables installed by then. Just another myth repeated time and time again by the poorly educated EV haters.

By the time all the fossil burners are scrapped, there will be no need for dinosaur fuel pumps. EV batteries are evolving so quickly that recharging will be much faster, needed less often etc, etc. Another myth perpetuated by the dinosaur ICE lovers. Don’t need ‘forecourts’ for kerb-side charging either. That will free up a lot of real estate used by dinosaur fuel suppliers.

Lastly, tyre wear claims are rubbish as well. There is very little difference between ICE and EV tyre wear when driven in a similar manor. Also luddite ICE owners forget/ignore the tiny amount of brake pad wear with EVs compared to ICE cars. Or they are simply poorly educated/informed of the way EVs use their electric motor(s) (in generator mode) to not only retard the vehicle but also to ‘recoup’ (as in recycle) the energy used for accelerating the car - not like ICE cars which waste all that energy by heating up the brakes.

So many stupid arguments against EVs and unjustifiable excuses for retaining fossil burning, polluting, toxic ICEs are simply the luddites clutching straws to try to justify carrying on with destroying our environment in so many ways.