Professional car reviewers

[SteveClem]

For years I've checked out car reviews in all the usual magazines. Very interesting they are too and when you are looking to make a big 'investment ' in a modern car they carry some weight. Years ago I decided not to get a new Vectra after Clarkson trashed it on the telly.
Now, I'm starting to get a bit sceptical these days. The last few modern cars we've bought have been highly rated in the professional reviews but have been disappointing. They all scored very high on 'refinement '. Is this another word for 'boring '?
Because I have time on my hands at this time of the year,and whilst researching our recent car change, I compared what the professional reviewers think to how real owners have found their cars. There doesn't seem to be any correlation between the two. Cars rated highly by the reviewers don't seem to be loved by owners and vice versa.
Are the professional reviewers influenced by driving too many up-market cars? Can they see the wood for the trees?
What do you think?

[amgrave]

I find with reviews that you best read between the lines and come to your own conclusions. As you read translate what they say using estate agent language ie good aspect means a large hole in the wall I prefer to use owners reviews than so called experts. I am sure they take back handers.

[TDV102]

I have had a number of Cavaliers, and good cars they were too, but Jezzer was 100% right about the Vectra. Vauxhall took all the good points from the Cavalier and binned them. I drove one and it was one of the most evil handling cars I have ever driven, terminal understeer as charged. Always try driving a car you fancy before parting with money is my motto, reviews give you an idea what to look for.

I do agree that refinement often means boring though. And soulless. My current Focus does everything very well, handles superbly and is economical, but is characterless. I need a Minor!

[irmscher]

I thought the Vectra was a good car and went well for John Clelland and Matt Neal .I think its a case of which engine and spec you go for.A lot of magazines and programmes are sponsored by car manufacturers .