Top Trunnions & Suspension Creaking
Posted: Wed Dec 07, 2011 7:49 pm
First off, apologies if this has been covered before, but I'm hoping someone can help!
My 1970 saloon which I use daily, had it's lower trunnions replaced recently by my local garage and the front ride height corectly re-set as it was riding too high. I supplied the parts and can see they have been replaced. I've used the garage for years and they are well-versed in older cars. The mechanic that did the work actually trained on Minors, so I'm confident he knows his stuff!
I've covered just short of 1k miles since, and a creaking noise has developed coming from the nearside front. I bounced the suspension and found that if I bounced it hard, it wouldn't creak, but if I bounced it gently, it would creak. Also it immediatley settled after bouncing so assumed the damper was OK. Incidentially, I have greased the front suspension since the work was done.
As the noise seemed to be coming from the bulkhead area, I wondered if it was the top trunnion bushes (as these were not replaced at the time) or the front damper being dry.
So I decided to replace the top trunnions as a matter of course and take the opportunity to inspect the front damper at the same time.
I bought new top trunnions from one of the Minor specialists complete with poly bushes. The damper seems fine, nice smooth but tight operation and it was topped up with oil, so I don't think this is the cause of the creaking. I also checked the swivel pin threads and they seem fine too....the car has only covered 52k from new.
However, when I tried to screw the new trunnion on the swivel pin, it seemed very difficult to turn (yes I did have the correct one on the correct side!!). I used a small amount of grease on the thread but it seemed very tight. It seemed to go on OK about halfway then got almost impossible to turn. As I was concerned about this I unwound it and decided against fitting it. So I used the old trunnion with the new poly bushes, new pivot bolt, washers and nuts.
To my annoyance, the bl**dy thing is still creaking and I've chosen not to drive it until I can get to the bottom of it.
So my questions are, do you know what the possible cause of the creaking is, and is the source of the creaking likely to be the lower bushes or something else? When driving the car it sounds like its coming from higher up ( i.e.bulkhead area).
Also, why won't the new trunnions screw onto the swivel pin easily? Is this poor quality parts and has anyone else had this problem? I thought I'd canvas opinions before going back to my garage about the lower bushes and the Minor specialist about the trunnions.
My 1970 saloon which I use daily, had it's lower trunnions replaced recently by my local garage and the front ride height corectly re-set as it was riding too high. I supplied the parts and can see they have been replaced. I've used the garage for years and they are well-versed in older cars. The mechanic that did the work actually trained on Minors, so I'm confident he knows his stuff!
I've covered just short of 1k miles since, and a creaking noise has developed coming from the nearside front. I bounced the suspension and found that if I bounced it hard, it wouldn't creak, but if I bounced it gently, it would creak. Also it immediatley settled after bouncing so assumed the damper was OK. Incidentially, I have greased the front suspension since the work was done.
As the noise seemed to be coming from the bulkhead area, I wondered if it was the top trunnion bushes (as these were not replaced at the time) or the front damper being dry.
So I decided to replace the top trunnions as a matter of course and take the opportunity to inspect the front damper at the same time.
I bought new top trunnions from one of the Minor specialists complete with poly bushes. The damper seems fine, nice smooth but tight operation and it was topped up with oil, so I don't think this is the cause of the creaking. I also checked the swivel pin threads and they seem fine too....the car has only covered 52k from new.
However, when I tried to screw the new trunnion on the swivel pin, it seemed very difficult to turn (yes I did have the correct one on the correct side!!). I used a small amount of grease on the thread but it seemed very tight. It seemed to go on OK about halfway then got almost impossible to turn. As I was concerned about this I unwound it and decided against fitting it. So I used the old trunnion with the new poly bushes, new pivot bolt, washers and nuts.
To my annoyance, the bl**dy thing is still creaking and I've chosen not to drive it until I can get to the bottom of it.
So my questions are, do you know what the possible cause of the creaking is, and is the source of the creaking likely to be the lower bushes or something else? When driving the car it sounds like its coming from higher up ( i.e.bulkhead area).
Also, why won't the new trunnions screw onto the swivel pin easily? Is this poor quality parts and has anyone else had this problem? I thought I'd canvas opinions before going back to my garage about the lower bushes and the Minor specialist about the trunnions.