I usually make my own out of cardboard. Yes, cereal packets are OK. Mainly because I can't be bothered to go and buy a new gasket. I use frosties, but I presume any packet will do

.
I happened to have a head set lying around when I did my last thermostat and used a cork gasket.

. Pure luxury!
The car runs so much better now it has a cork gasket.
As BMC says, be careful of broken studs and make sure the mating surfaces are clean, it'll be fine.
Andrew
Maggie, 1969, 4 door, Almond Green.
And Project "Traveller"...
[sig]4253[/sig]