
Possibly a poor connection between the points mounting plate and ground? That can cause all kind of ####. I've only had that once and it was on a motorbike, and I started playing with it at the top of the biggest hill in a 10 mile radius from where I lived, quite near a trig point - you can guess the outcome... bottom of hill and still not started.So I have no idea what's wrong with the first distributor, I guess I'll dismantle it and see sometime, but after the three or four days it's wasted for me I won't be in a hurry to experiment! (And I can stop feeling completely incompetent!)
Badly earthing points mounting plate is not unheard of with Minors, albeit very rare - most likely culprit is the little (often unseen) grounding wire.
That makes no difference if you follow common sense. With #1 on the compression stroke (checked using finger on the spark plug hole) the position of the rotor arm shows you exactly which terminal on the dizzy cap to use for #1 spark plug lead.It may have been assembled 180 degrees round relative to the offset dog on the drive spindle. Thus the sparks would be 180 degrees out!